Writing Shotgun

A SCHOOL BOARD RACE THAT REMINDS US OF 2006, AND NOT IN A GOOD WAY

 

A candidate in the contest to replace Michael Ellis faces the same accusation Ellis did three years ago: carpetbagger

Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the voting booth, the contest to replace former Long Beach Unified Board of Education member Michael Shane Ellis looms Dec. 29. And—call this Ellis II: Electric Boogaloo, or The Ellis Strikes Back, or some other catchy sequel name—already the allegations of carpetbagging are flying.

Here, briefly, is the situation, though my cover story in Wednesday’s print edition of The District Weekly has more on the race.

Three years ago, you’ll recall that Ellis himself came under fire for allegedly moving into the school board’s District 3 less than 30 days before filing campaign papers to represent it.

This time, the alleged culprit is candidate Kate Erin Conrath, 25, a Los Angeles Unified School District substitute teacher—whose cell phone, it should be noted, still has an Illinois prefix—and, for some, the allegation against her is the only thing intriguing about this election. (They’re wrong about that.)

“The only interesting quirk about [this race] is, that’s what happened with Ellis,” says Long Beach political consultant Jeffrey Adler, who has been hired to manage the campaign of one of Conrath’s four competitors, retired former PTA president Pauline Gonzalez Stenberg.

(The race’s other three candidates are United Cambodian Community Associate Project Director Raymond Chavarria, financial controller Richard G. Lewis, Jr., and John McGinnis, a retired Cerritos Community College dean.)

“I thought this was why you were calling,” City Attorney Robert Shannon says when I reach him to talk about some of the race’s other issues.

Shannon quickly confirms that, yes, a representative of Long Beach Unified School District has contacted the city to raise the possibility that candidate Conrath is indeed a carpetbagger.

But Shannon and Assistant City Attorney Heather Mahood are almost as quick to say emphatically that the city will not be going after Conrath on this one.

“We know that it’s an issue because we’ve been approached,” Shannon says.

But, adds Mahood over the speakerphone: “It’s really not our call; it’s the county or the school district’s call. We’re not going to keep anybody off the ballot.”

Reached on her cell phone, Conrath explains why, nearly four years after moving to California, she only this month registered to vote in this state and is still updating her vehicle registration and her driver’s-license information.

“It’s something I’m kicking myself for. I didn’t see the opportunity coming to me,” Conrath says. “I’m obviously in favor of Ellis resigning as soon as he did, but I wasn’t counting on it. It kind of just came up.”

A Chicago native, Conrath says she moved to Long Beach in early 2006, living first in the 100 block of W. Sixth St., then moving a year-and-a-half ago to the 400 block of W. Seventh St., where she lives now.

Her residency became an issue, Conrath says, because despite moving across the country, she kept returning home to care for her father‚ and thus never updated any of her information.

“I don’t want to pull out the card, but Ellis wasn’t a resident for 30 days” before he ran, Conrath says—all but pulling out the card as she speaks. “I think the whole point of it is that somebody doesn’t just move into the district and try to take over the district.”

That is the point. But unlike in 2006—when Long Beach Unified took Ellis to court—no one seems to be ready for litigation this time.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

  • sarahwingfield
    Since when do we persecute people for moving?? Did anyone look into the fact that Kate received her Masters in CA? Or how about that she gave of herself for teach for America in the Long Beach area? Certainly doesn't make me think carpetbagger.
  • Chargers1
    Give me a break. People move to the area from all over the country, and she's been here for four years. If she had immigrated to here from outside the country, as many local residents have, would we be asking the same questions? She has worked in area schools, lived in Long Beach, and it appears as though she is here to stay. The "carpetbagger" label is rediculous from what I can see.
  • Nora
    What's everyone so rip-roaring mad about? Conrath's reluctance to terminate ties with Illinois could also be read as a sign that she is deeply commited to not only one, but two communities in which she's lived. That's more of a contribution than most of us make, and I commend Conrath for digging into Long Beach community issues after a relatively short time living there. I know that after only a few years teaching in my community, I was fully entrenched in its educational realities as well as committed to improving them. It's Conrath's ideas about and insight into education that should be discussed, not her cell phone prefix. I know lots of people who haven't changed their area codes in much more than four years, if only to make sure they don't lose touch with people who are dear to them. Who's to say the same isn't true for Conrath?

    I think we should wait to hear what she has to say about education before she is so hastily dismissed as a carpetbagger. Four years is plenty long to love a place, to want to contribute to it. Why assume that Conrath doesn't?
  • Nora: I think we should be more interested in how Conrath feels about abiding by our laws and in an explanation of why she appears to have failed to do so in at least two instances before we consider her for *any* elected position, School Board or otherwise.

    Beyond that, if she's elected I don't much care what area code she prefers to use as long as she answers the phone when it rings (unlike her predecessor) and I don't much care where she lives in her District so long as she bothers to show up for work consistently and represent her constituents and our community as she would be swearing an oath to do (also unlike her predecessor).
  • cutshurt
    Is this really the story in this race? You have four other candidates that are serious contenders with strong campaigns up and running. The alleged carpetbagger is the least serious candidate in the bunch. I mean, it's not like there is nothing going on in the education world at the moment. Hey DW, return to discussing the issues and the real candidates please.
  • howardx
    "the guy before me was a carpetbagger so its ok if i am". interesting theory.
  • howardx
    2 first time posters here to defend the carpetbagger, amatuerish at best.
  • Conrath states: "I’m obviously in favor of Ellis resigning as soon as he did, but I wasn’t counting on it. It kind of just came up.”

    As soon as he did? Ellis was an absentee School Board Member for MONTHS and, in December 2007, selfishly and publicly refused to resign even after being formally asked by a majority of his Board colleagues to do so! The question of Ellis' resignation had been on the public record for almost 2 years before he finally manned-up (in a sneaky and cowardly sort of way) and did so. It didn't just "kind of come up".

    Conrath claims to have moved to Long Beach in early 2006 yet "is still updating her vehicle registration and her driver’s-license information."

    Really?

    I wonder if she is aware that when she moved here she was required to obtain a California driver license within 10 days [CVC 12505(c)] and she was required to apply for California registration of her vehicle within 20 days after the Illinois registration became due (CVC 4152.5)?

    Allegations of carpetbagging don't concern me half so much in this case as do reasonable concerns that Ms. Conrath may be no more interested in abiding by our laws than Ellis was.
  • The Toad
    Amen that, Brother Jonn!
blog comments powered by Disqus
 

© 2007-2008 Seven Days Publishing LLC.